This topic is in response to a previous post inquiring as to the merits of sangu kaku as bonsai.  Hopefully it sheds light on several of the issues raised in the previous post.  

Before I knew much about bonsai, I started this sangu kaku from nursery stock 15 years ago, as I was attracted to the pink bark and light green foliage.  I have been pleased with the tree's development.  Overall, this sangu kaku has responded well to shaping, and internode length is average, compared to other japanese maple.  The tree is 20" tall, seen here in summer color in a 16" pot.



What I have come to understand, from personal experience with this particular tree:

1. Pink bark is present on young shoots, the color fades to light yellow, light green and ultimately grey with age.  The natural habit of branches is upward growing, but branches can be easily brought to more gentle upward going to horizontal as desired.
2. Spring foliage is pink tinged, but in general light yellow/green.  Summer foliage darkens a bit, yet still light green (lighter than most other japanese maple).  I would not consider sangu kaku a red cultivar.  Growth behavior is similar to other japanese maple.
3. Fall color ranges from light pink, light orange and ends in brilliant yellow (based on weather conditions).
4. Easily air-layered.  The second trunk is a layer from the larger.  This was my first layer, and was done when I had limited personal experience.  
5. Nebari behave similar to other japanese maple, and can be encouraged to spread with a shallow pot.

These images illustrate several of the above points.











Overall, sangu kaku has been a reasonable, if not favorable choice for me to establish a nice japanese maple bonsai.  The only reservation I would have is stock, somewhat hard to find.  Most commonly found in a garden center for landscape, and many of these are grafts.  Grafts of japanese maple in general terms can complicated development of nebari and trunk base.  In retrospect, I was lucky to find this tree on it's own roots.  If grafted garden center stock is the only option, several of the upper branches could be layered for a nice grouping, and the base could be layered above the graft.




 **hot-linked images removed**

This maple is just gorgeous.

Art

I will apologize now, if I am asking an obvious questions, but I am very new to bonsai.  How big (Trunk diameter and overall height) was the tree when you purchased it as nursery stock?  What part of the country are you in, that you could find this in a nursery store?  Finally, how many years from nursery pot to training pot to bonsai pot?  Thanks.  I think your tree is graceful and beautiful.

Jacksmom,

All good questions ... no need to apologize.

This tree was started in Seattle.  Forgive me, at the time, I was young to bonsai.  Made no records, pics, etc ... so this is from memory, started greater than 15 years ago.  As memory serves me ...

Nursery stock trunk was 3/4", total height was 3' or more.  I cut the tree down to about 18" shortly after purchase and put in ground.  In the next 1-2 years, reading more about bonsai, I chose to layer, getting second trunk.  Year later, took out of ground and positioned both trunks in bonsai pot.  Developed in oversized bonsai pot for next ten years.  Moved to Minnesota, wintered in greenhouse.  Three years ago, I planted into a shallow pot, the one pictured, to increase root spread.  Those have been the best three years in development.  Trunk girth increasing, as well as root spread.  Root spread now at about 5-6" (depends how much moss you take off), largest trunk now about 1.5" above root spread.

Thanks for your interest,

Josh

I have to agree with everyone, just an awesome tree.  When I first looked at it, I thought, "the second branch on the mother trunk is thicker than the first branch.  The other trunk has a super thick branch that looks out of place..", but then I stepped back and I just really like this tree.  Yeah, it might not have a "perfect" winter image, but it looks damn good in leaf.  Loved all the stages from spring growth, to summer growth, to fall color.  Did you airlayer or groundlayer the nursery stock?

Thank you all for your kind remarks ...

pwk5017 the mother tree is on her own (original) roots, daughter tree was air layered.

I agree with your technical criticisms, many of which I am trying to correct. I have been working on increasing size of lowest left branch, to balance the large branch above it and across it on the daughter tree.  The tree really took off with a bit of fertilizer this year, so maintaing form became an issue.  Tree has also become very ramified and dense, this summer's summer image taken with nearly every second leaf removed, partial defoliation.  Also, roots starting to climb out of pot.  May need slightly wider and deeper pot next year.  Despite the technical limitations of the tree, it still puts a smile on my face, just about any time of the year.

Best wishes, Josh

Nice tree! I'd love to see an update as well!

Whoa, that picture didn't work out so well.  Will try again!